Insights Library
Minister approval is not the end: High Court leaves the door open to challenge Planning Scheme Amendments
The High Court judgment in Minister for Planning v IGA Retail Services Pty Ltd & Ors [2026] HCA 43 was handed down on 11 November 2026. The Minister was granted special leave to appeal a decision of the Court of Appeal to the High Court that concerned section 39 of the Planning and Environment Act 1987 (Vic) (the Act), with the High Court ultimately dismissing the Minister’s appeal.
The key takeaways from the judgment include:
- A decision in relation to a planning scheme amendment may still be challenged in the Supreme Court where the alleged defect amounts to jurisdictional error. Examples of jurisdictional error may include legal unreasonableness, failing to consider relevant submissions or failing to provide adequate reasons.
- This remains possible whether a planning scheme amendment is awaiting approval or has already been approved.
- Not every procedural error in the planning scheme amendment process will amount to jurisdictional error, and the available grounds and remedies will depend on the statutory requirement and circumstances.
In summary, the High Court dismissed the Minister’s appeal and confirmed that section 39 of the Act does not prevent a person with sufficient standing from commencing a proceeding in the Supreme Court seeking relief for jurisdictional error. Before approval of an amendment, section 39(8) does not prevent a person with sufficient standing from seeking judicial review for jurisdictional error. Importantly to your proceeding, after approval of an amendment, section 39(7) only protects an amendment from invalidity arising from non-jurisdictional procedural failures, but does not validate an amendment affected by jurisdictional error. Whether a particular procedural failure constitutes jurisdictional error depends on the proper construction of the relevant statutory provision.
The judgment provides certainty for those seeking to bring judicial review proceedings for jurisdictional error in relation to planning scheme amendments. The judgment also broadly endorses the judgment in East Melbourne Group Inc v Minister for Planning (2008) 23 VR 605 that section 39(7) does not protect against an action being brought for jurisdictional errors.
Background and Facts
Section 39 of the Act relates to planning scheme amendments and defects in procedure. Relevantly, the two key subsections the High Court was required to interpret were sections 39(7) and 39(8), which state:
(7) An amendment which has been approved is not made invalid by any failure to comply with Division 1 or 2 or this Division or Part 8.
(8) Except for an application under this section, a person cannot bring an action in respect of a failure to comply with Division 1 or 2 or this Division or Part 8 in relation to an amendment which has not been approved.
Divisions 1 to 3 of Part 3 concern provisions dealing with exhibition, notice and adoption, public submissions and approval of amendments. Part 8 concerns panels appointed under the Act, including the conduct of hearings and the preparation of panel reports.
In 2023, Greater Shepparton City Council were given authorisation from the Minister to prepare and exhibit Amendment C245 to the Shepparton Planning Scheme (Amendment). Following submissions, the Minister appointed a panel who produced a panel report. The Council ultimately resolved to adopt the Amendment subject to the panel’s recommended changes. The Amendment remained unapproved at the time of the High Court hearing.
In June 2024, IGA Retail Services Pty Ltd and Shepparton Pty Ltd (IGA Parties) commenced judicial review proceedings in the Supreme Court. The IGA Parties sought an injunction restraining the Minister from approving the Amendment under s 35 of the Act. The IGA Parties also sought certiorari to quash the Council’s resolution adopting the Amendment with the changes recommended by the Panel.
The IGA Parties contended that the Panel report was legally unreasonable, that the Panel failed to consider the substantial submissions made by the applicants, and that the Panel gave inadequate reasons, and therefore the panel’s report was affected by jurisdictional error and invalid.
The trial judge reserved two questions of law to the Court of Appeal of the Supreme Court of Victoria:
- Question 1: Does s 39 of the Act prevent the IGA Parties from seeking the relief sought in the originating motion filed in the proceeding?
- Question 2: To the extent necessary to decide Question 1, was the decision in East Melbourne Group Inc v Minister for Planning (2008) 23 VR 605, as to the construction of s 39 of the Act, plainly wrong?
The Court of Appeal answered question 1 “no” and question 2 unnecessary to answer.
High Court majority judgment
Gageler CJ, Gordon, Edelman, Jagot and Beech-Jones JJ delivered joint reasons. The majority agreed with the Court of Appeal’s answer to Question 1, held that East Melbourne was correctly decided subject to one qualification, and dismissed the appeal.
The Minister’s broad argument was that section 39(7) necessarily implied that a failure to comply with Divisions 1 to 3 of Part 3 or Part 8 could not invalidate any step preceding the approval of an amendment. Although section 39(7) expressly applies to an amendment that “has been approved”, the Minister contended that it necessarily followed that the same failures could not invalidate an amendment, or an anterior step in the amendment process, before approval.
Given this construction of section 39(7), the Minister argued that the prohibition in section 39(8) applied to the IGA Parties proceeding. The Minister contended that section 39(8) prevented the IGA Parties from seeking an injunction restraining approval of the Amendment and certiorari quashing the Council’s adoption decision, notwithstanding that the proceeding alleged jurisdictional error.
The majority held that section 39 does not prevent the Supreme Court from exercising its “supervisory jurisdiction” to grant relief for jurisdictional error in relation to the amendment process. In relation to an approved amendment, section 39(7) protects the amendment from invalidity arising from non-jurisdictional failures to comply with the specified provisions, but does not validate an approved amendment affected by jurisdictional error. At Paragraph 67 the majority found:
“The result of the preceding analysis is that s 39(7), alone or in conjunction with any of the other aspects of the PE Act to which the Minister referred, does not have the effect that a step anterior to the approval of an amendment is incapable of being invalid for jurisdictional error. Nor does s 39(8) prevent the Supreme Court from granting relief. Consequently, whether the Alleged Jurisdictional Errors are established is to be determined at trial in the Judicial Review Proceeding.”
The Minister sought to give section 39(7), which expressly operates in respect of an amendment that has been approved, a broader operation whereby, by necessary implication, failures to comply with the specified provisions could not invalidate steps in the amendment process before approval. The majority rejected that construction as contrary to the express terms of s 39(7) at paragraph 52. The majority, at paragraph 56, also found that the Minister’s contention is “also inconsistent with other provisions in the Act that contemplate that specific failures to comply may or may not result in the invalidity of a step or decision anterior to approval.”
The majority cited section 20(3)(a) as a provision that would be inconsistent with the Minister’s construction of section 39(7). This provision prevents the Minister from exempting a planning authority from a requirement to give notice to the owner of land if the amendment provides for the reservation of that land for public purposes, or the closure of a road which provides access to that land. The majority found that “it would be odd for such a provision to exist if the Minister could innocently fail to comply with it, but the failure to comply could not affect the validity of the exemption.”
The majority held that section 39(8) cannot prevent a person with sufficient standing from invoking the Supreme Court’s “supervisory jurisdiction” to seek relief for jurisdictional error. Consistently with Plaintiff S157/2002 v Commonwealth (2003) 211 CLR 476 and Kirk v Industrial Court of New South Wales (2010)239 CLR 531, State legislation cannot validly withdraw or diminish a State Supreme Court’s constitutionally entrenched jurisdiction to review jurisdictional error. The majority held at paragraph 65:
“…The observations made by the majority in Kirk about the constitutional significance of the supervisory jurisdiction of a State Supreme Court were expressly stated to “point to the continued need for, and utility of, the distinction between jurisdictional and non-jurisdictional error in the Australian constitutional context”. As their Honours stated, “[l]egislation which would take from a State Supreme Court power to grant relief on account of jurisdictional error is beyond State legislative power. Legislation which denies the availability of relief for non-jurisdictional error of law appearing on the face of the record is not beyond power.” The proper construction of s 39(8) involves no enlargement of the principles expressed in Kirk.”
Accordingly, section 39(8) does not prevent the bringing an action in the Supreme Court seeking relief for jurisdictional error. Consistently, section 39(7) does not operate to validate an approved amendment affected by jurisdictional error, although it protects an approved amendment from invalidity arising from non-jurisdictional failures to comply with specified provisions.
East Melbourne
Although the Court of Appeal had considered it unnecessary to answer Question 2, the High Court majority went further and held that East Melbourne was, subject to one qualification, correctly decided.
The majority agreed with the central proposition in East Melbourne that section 39(7) does not protect an approved amendment against invalidity arising from jurisdictional error. However, it qualified that case’s distinction between mere “procedural” errors and jurisdictional errors, a procedural error can itself be jurisdictional, depending upon the proper construction of the particular statutory requirement and the facts. East Melbourne should therefore be understood as treating section 39(7) as protecting approved amendments from non-jurisdictional errors, rather than from jurisdictional errors. The majority found at paragraph 70:
“Consistent with the earlier analysis of the statutory scheme, and subject to one qualification, East Melbourne was correctly decided. The qualification is that East Melbourne was decided prior to Kirk and, in addressing s 39(7), drew a distinction between non-compliance with procedural requirements and decisions tainted by jurisdictional error. Not all “procedural errors” are non-jurisdictional. Whether an error is jurisdictional is determined as a matter of statutory construction of the particular statutory provision, applied to the particular facts and circumstances in issue. For that reason, the construction of s 39(7) adopted in East Melbourne should be understood as concerned with non-jurisdictional errors. That construction gives s 39(7) a harmonious and coherent operation with the construction of s 39 in its operation in relation to an amendment which has not been approved.”
As such, the Minister’s appeal was dismissed by the majority. Steward J and Gleeson J delivered separate dissenting judgments.
In summary, whether a defect in procedure is a jurisdictional error or not, will depend upon the construction of the statute. However, this is a welcome decision for developers seeking to challenge a planning authority’s decision where it has invoked a jurisdictional error, such as:
- Legal unreasonableness;
- Failing to consider relevant submissions; or
- Failing to provide adequate reasons.
And the mere fact that the amendment has been approved, does not obviate the ability to seek certiorari to quash an authority’s position.
This is also a timely judgment that clarifies the ability to judicially review decisions made in relation to a planning scheme amendment process, given the recent releases of several Advisory Committee Reports and Planning Scheme Amendment approvals. If you have any questions about any recent planning scheme amendment decisions may impact any potential judicial review, please do not hesitate to contact our office.